Results from three randomised controlled trials in South Africa, Kenya
and Uganda,
in 2006 showed that following circumcision, the incidence of HIV infection was
reduced in men by more than half.
According to the new policy document, circumcision will
be rolled out for males of all ages in a culturally sensitive way and in a
clinically safe setting.
The programme will involve some strengthening of the
health infrastructure, but according to Peter Mutie, head of communications at
the National AIDS Control Council (NACC), the existing health centres are
sufficiently equipped for the rollout.
"We are trying to fast track it so that by mid-2008
we can start rolling it out," Mutie told IRIN/PlusNews.
Although a handful of ethnic communities in Kenya - including the Luo, Suba and Teso in
western Kenya and the
Turkana in northwestern Kenya
- do not practice circumcision culturally, Mutie said the government's
programme would focus on the whole country.
"Most of our tribes practice circumcision as a rite
of passage, but many do it traditionally, using the same blade for several
boys, a practice we would like to eradicate; others don't remove the entire
foreskin, which is the medical way to do it - they just cut off a bit of
it," he said.
Mutie added that in order to limit resistance to the
programme, social mobilisation exercises would precede the rollout, with
community members being trained to educate their peers on the benefits of male
circumcision.
"This is a programme that needs very careful
implementation, and education is key - for instance, people need to know that
it is not in any way a guarantee of protection from HIV," Mutie said.
"
He stressed that traditional circumcisers would play a
key role in re-educating their communities. "We cannot totally remove their
role - they are useful advisers whom people look up to, so they can be taught
to advise the young initiates on safe sex and other healthy practices," he
added.
The news about a national policy will be good news for
many NGOs and medical practitioners who have been awaiting guidance on male
circumcision. Among these is Marie Stopes Kenya, which started a pilot project
on male circumcision in western Kenya
a year ago using World Health Organization guidelines. The organisation is part
of the national male circumcision task force.
Testing the waters
"Our pilot is a free mobile outreach, where a team
of five members - a doctor, clinical officer, care assistant, nurse and driver
- goes into various communities and sets up camp in a room at a local medical
centre or in a tent, and invites people to come or bring their children for
circumcision," said George Obhai, monitoring and evaluation manager at
Marie Stopes Kenya.
Before the mobile team arrives, the local hospital or
clinic is contacted to conduct community mobilisation, and on the day every man
getting circumcised receives counselling from a trained member of staff before
the procedure is carried out.
"Interestingly, many of the ideas people have about
male circumcision work in our favour, even among the Luo; for example, people
believe that it improves the sexual experience and that ladies prefer
circumcised men," he added.
Obhai noted that male circumcision has not been a
hard sell in western Kenya
because the Luo, Teso and Suba are surrounded by circumcising communities, and
many of them know people who have been circumcised. The HIV prevention benefits
it offers, also made the practice popular in the region.
In four districts of Nyanza Province,
more than 2,700 men have volunteered for circumcision through Marie Stopes
since April 2007, and the numbers are increasing every month; 80 percent of the
men and boys being circumcised are from traditionally non-circumcising
communities.
But this success is not uniform; among the Turkana of
northwestern Kenya,
an isolated and very traditional society, it has been much harder to push the
circumcision agenda.
"When we took the mobile team to Turkana last year,
we got two cases on one outreach day, on another day we got three cases,"
Obhai said. "We pulled out because we simply didn't have the financial
resources to justify continuing at the time, but once we are able to set up
some more mobile teams we will go back to the region."
Marie Stopes also uses people from within the community
as peer educators, and hopes to incorporate the traditional circumcisers into
their programmes.
"In the past we have experienced resistance from
them [traditional circumcisers], as we are perceived as trying to take away
their source of income or their role in society," Obhai said. "For
instance, in many areas, this coming August is a circumcising period, so we'd
like to encourage them to maintain their role as counsellors and even pay them
an allowance for that, but to bring the boys to the clinic for circumcision."
The pilot has been particularly successful in reaching
rural populations with little access to modern medical facilities, and
prisoners, who also lack access to healthcare. The social mobilisation is also
being used as an entry point for education about the traditional ABC -
Abstinence, Be faithful and use a Condom - prevention strategy, as well as as
an avenue for promoting voluntary counselling and testing.
Marie Stopes' outreach has recorded five complications
with the procedure in the year it has been operational - two adverse reactions
to the anaesthetic and three post-op infections.
The organisation intends to replicate its mobile
outreach across the country following the success of the Nyanza experience.